Stimulus Update: Bring Back the Bridge to Nowhere!

In an earlier post, I compared the stimulus package to the infamous “Bridge to Nowhere” project in terms of  job creation per dollar spent.  I concluded that the stimulus was about 20% more efficient than the Ketchikan-Gravina Bridge.  I WAS WRONG.   I was comparing apples to oranges:  based on data, I assumed the bridge project would employ 470 people in its construction — I did not take into account the multiplier effect of those jobs (the fact that construction materials purchased and the wages spent by those workers directly employed in the project will indirectly generate other jobs).  On the other hand, the Congressional Budget Office estimate takes into account multiplier effect in assessing the stimulus bill’s impact.   To put the comparisons on a level playing field, I assume a multiplier of 1.76 (cited here, but seems to be representative of the estimates I can find for construction job multipliers), which indicates that the Bridge project would have generated a total of 827 jobs.

Updating the calculations for the “trimmed” package:

Stimulus: $789 Billion / 2.6 Million jobs (mid-point of CBO estimates) = $303,462 per job created

Bridge to Nowhere: $190 Million / 827 jobs = $229,746

Obviously, there’s lots of rough estimates in these calculations, but it is ironic that a widely heralded example of horrendous government waste, when compared to the stimulus package, is actually more efficient..  Maybe “ironic” isn’t the right word.  Sad?  Shameful?  Embarrassing?  You pick.


3 Responses to “Stimulus Update: Bring Back the Bridge to Nowhere!”

  1. James Brady Says:


    If you read your SA article of the same stripe written on you Blog re: stimulus and bridges to nowhere, you have a couple of challenging counter opinions. Care to execrcise you intellectual and financial muscle?

  2. Grading the Stimulus « (in)efficient frontiers Says:

    […] (in)efficient frontiers Inefficient Frontiers: insight on our less-than-efficient markets and the risks of life on the investment frontier « Stimulus Update: Bring Back the Bridge to Nowhere! […]

  3. Stimulus Package: Efficiently Building a Bridge to Nowhere? « (in)efficient frontiers Says:

    […] ***** PLEASE SEE UPDATED AND CORRECTED ENTRY OF 2/13/09 HERE ***** […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: